Notebookcheck Logo

İnceleme: AMD Radeon HD 8970M

Uygun fiyat. AMD, Nvidia karşısına bir rakip çıkardı. Radeon HD 8970M üst sınıfa yeni bir soluk getirecek gibi. İncelememiz özellikle iki soru üzerine yoğunlaşıyor: Performans GeForce GTX 770M veya GTX 780M ile yarışabilir mi? AMD iyi çalışan bir sürücü sunuyor mu?
AMD vs. Nvidia

Radeon HD 7970M sadece bir yıl öncesine kadar Intel modelleri ile yarışırken Radeon HD 8970M modelini teste tabii tutuyoruz. AMD fiyat/performans puanlarını kazanacak mı yoksa yine sürücü sorunları ile mı karşılaşacak? Performansın dışında kartın özellikleri, sıcaklık değeleri ve güç tüketimini de inceliyoruz.

Test system

One, Radeon HD 8970M grafik kartını kullanımımıza sunan ilk üreticilerden biri. 17 inç Clevo barebone içinde grafik kartı yüksek skorlar peşinde. DirectX 11 modeli 8 GB DDR3 RAM ve Core i7-4700MQ işlemciye sahip.

One K73-3N (Clevo P170SM)
One K73-3N (Clevo P170SM)
One K73-3N (Clevo P170SM)
One K73-3N (Clevo P170SM)
One K73-3N (Clevo P170SM)
System information

Özellikler

Strictly speaking, AMD's new high-end graphics card is only a faster version of the Radeon HD 7970M, which is also based on the GCN architecture. Apart from the core clock (900 vs. 850 MHz) and the memory clock (1250 vs. 1200 MHz) most of the specs are identical.

1280 shader units, 2.8 billion transistors, and a 256-bit interface hint at excellent performance. We feel doubling the RAM (4096 vs. 2048 MB GDDR5) was not necessary. Apparently, AMD wants to stand up to the GTX 780M in marketing. Nvidia's top model also features a memory bandwidth of 160 GB/s.

Radeon HD 8970M
Radeon HD 8970M
Radeon HD 8970M
Radeon HD 8970M
GeForce GTX 770M
GeForce GTX 770M
GeForce GTX 770M
GeForce GTX 770M
GeForce GTX 780M
GeForce GTX 780M
GeForce GTX 780M
GeForce GTX 780M


Grafik Kartı GeForce GTX 770M GeForce GTX 680M GeForce GTX 780M Radeon HD 7970M Radeon HD 8970M
Mimari Kepler Kepler Kepler GCN GCN
Üretim 28 nm 28 nm 28 nm 28 nm 28 nm
Shader üniteleri 960 1344 1536 1280 1280
Transistörler 3540 millions 3540 millions 3540 millions 2800 millions 2800 millions
Çekirdek saati 811 MHz 720 MHz 823 MHz 850 MHz 900 MHz
Bellek saati 1000 MHz 900 MHz 1250 MHz 1200 MHz 1250 MHz
Bellek türü GDDR5 GDDR5 GDDR5 GDDR5 GDDR5
Bellek kapasitesi 3072 MB 4096 MB 4096 MB 2048 MB 4096 MB
Bellek arayüzü 192 Bit 256 Bit 256 Bit 256 Bit 256 Bit
Bellek genişliği 96.2 GB/s 115.2 GB/Sek 160 GB/s 153.6 GB/s 160 GB/s

Enduro

Enduro adındaki dahili ve harici grafik kartları arası değişimi sağlayan sistem HD 7970M'den bu yana oldukça gelişmiş. AMD sadece performansı arttırmakla kalmayıp yeni fonksiyonlar da eklemiş.

Catalyst Control merkezindeki özel menüler sayesinde kişisel ayarlamalar yapmak mümkün.

Nvidia'nın Optimus teknolojisi halen Enduro'ya kıyasla daha gelişmiş. Ancak bu AMD grafik kartını almanıza bir engel değil.

Ancak kart değişimi bazen performans düşüşüsne sebep olabilmekte. Kısaca Nvidia grafik kartları bu noktada daha iyi performans sunmakta.

Sürücü

Halen AMD'nin resmi sürücülerini tavsiye etmiyoruz. 13.4 ve 13.6 Beta Catalyst versiyonları 8000 serisi için tasarlanmış olmasına karşın, kurulum hata göstermemesine rağmen çeşitli sorunlarla karşılaştık.

Bazı oyun ve testlerin çalışmamasının yanı sıra, birçoğu da takılı kalmakta ve sinir bozucu grafik hataları gözlemlenebilmekte.

Bunun Clevo Barebone kaynaklı mı yoksa AMD tabanlı mı olduğunu şu an için söyleyemiyoruz. Clevo sürücüsü ile Radeon HD 8970M neredeyse hatasız çalışmakta. Testlerimizde tek bir sistem çökmesi veya mavi ekran ile karşılaşmadık. 

Sentetik testler

 

Sentetik testlerde grafik kartı harika bir sonuç vermekte. Genellikle daha pahalı olan GeForce 770M, AMD'ye karşı duramıyor. Ancak lider GeForce GTX 780M

Kartın fiyatına bakarak konuşacak olursak, performans harika.

Unigine Heaven 3.0 - 1920x1080 DX 11, Normal Tessellation, High Shaders AA:Off AF:Off (sort by value)
Radeon HD 8970M (12.103.0.0) / Core i7-4700MQ
One K73-3N
61.1 fps
GeForce GTX 770M (320.49) / Core i7-4700MQ
One K73-3N
51 fps -17%
GeForce GTX 780M (320.49) / Core i7-4700MQ
One K73-3N
76.8 fps +26%
Unigine Heaven 2.1 - 1280x1024 high, Tesselation (normal), DirectX11 AA:off AF:1x (sort by value)
Radeon HD 8970M (12.103.0.0) / Core i7-4700MQ
One K73-3N
89.3 fps
GeForce GTX 770M (320.49) / Core i7-4700MQ
One K73-3N
68.1 fps -24%
GeForce GTX 780M (320.49) / Core i7-4700MQ
One K73-3N
101.3 fps +13%
3DMark
1920x1080 Fire Strike Graphics (sort by value)
Radeon HD 8970M (12.103.0.0) / Core i7-4700MQ
One K73-3N
5110 Points
GeForce GTX 770M (320.49) / Core i7-4700MQ
One K73-3N
3729 Points -27%
GeForce GTX 780M (320.49) / Core i7-4700MQ
One K73-3N
5744 Points +12%
1280x720 Cloud Gate Standard Graphics (sort by value)
Radeon HD 8970M (12.103.0.0) / Core i7-4700MQ
One K73-3N
32474 Points
GeForce GTX 770M (320.49) / Core i7-4700MQ
One K73-3N
24948 Points -23%
GeForce GTX 780M (320.49) / Core i7-4700MQ
One K73-3N
37652 Points +16%
1280x720 Ice Storm Standard Graphics (sort by value)
Radeon HD 8970M (12.103.0.0) / Core i7-4700MQ
One K73-3N
137945 Points
GeForce GTX 770M (320.49) / Core i7-4700MQ
One K73-3N
136401 Points -1%
GeForce GTX 780M (320.49) / Core i7-4700MQ
One K73-3N
141592 Points +3%
3DMark 11 - 1280x720 Performance GPU (sort by value)
Radeon HD 8970M (12.103.0.0) / Core i7-4700MQ
One K73-3N
6818 Points
GeForce GTX 770M (320.49) / Core i7-4700MQ
One K73-3N
5234 Points -23%
GeForce GTX 780M (320.49) / Core i7-4700MQ
One K73-3N
8014 Points +18%
3DMark Vantage - 1280x1024 P GPU no PhysX (sort by value)
Radeon HD 8970M (12.103.0.0) / Core i7-4700MQ
One K73-3N
23882 Points
GeForce GTX 770M (320.49) / Core i7-4700MQ
One K73-3N
19524 Points -18%
GeForce GTX 780M (320.49) / Core i7-4700MQ
One K73-3N
28220 Points +18%
3DMark 06 - 1280x1024 Standard Score AA:0x AF:0x (sort by value)
Radeon HD 8970M (12.103.0.0) / Core i7-4700MQ
One K73-3N
23383 Points
GeForce GTX 770M (320.49) / Core i7-4700MQ
One K73-3N
22486 Points -4%
GeForce GTX 780M (320.49) / Core i7-4700MQ
One K73-3N
22770 Points -3%

CAD testleri

AMD, CAD'i domine etmesiyle biliniyor ve bu mevcut jenerasyonla da değişmemiş. Aşağıdaki tabloya göre Radeon HD 8970M kolaylıkla diğer üst modelleri geride bırakıyor. GeForce GTX 780M bile bazı testlerde %40-90 daha yavaş kalabilmekte.

SPECviewperf 11
1920x1080 Siemens NX (sort by value)
Radeon HD 8970M (12.103.0.0) / Core i7-4700MQ
One K73-3N
15.76 fps
Radeon HD 7970M (8.934.2.0) / Core i7-3610QM
Alienware M17x R4
13.84 fps -12%
GeForce GTX 680M (302.72) / Core i7-3720QM
Schenker XMG P702
2.1 fps -87%
GeForce GTX 770M (311.27) / Core i7-4800MQ
One K73-3N
2.26 fps -86%
GeForce GTX 780M (311.27) / Core i7-4700MQ
One K56-3N2
2.52 fps -84%
1920x1080 Tcvis (sort by value)
Radeon HD 8970M (12.103.0.0) / Core i7-4700MQ
One K73-3N
7.82 fps
Radeon HD 7970M (8.934.2.0) / Core i7-3610QM
Alienware M17x R4
6.47 fps -17%
GeForce GTX 680M (302.72) / Core i7-3720QM
Schenker XMG P702
0.9 fps -88%
GeForce GTX 770M (311.27) / Core i7-4800MQ
One K73-3N
1.1 fps -86%
GeForce GTX 780M (311.27) / Core i7-4700MQ
One K56-3N2
0.94 fps -88%
1920x1080 SolidWorks (sort by value)
Radeon HD 8970M (12.103.0.0) / Core i7-4700MQ
One K73-3N
29.57 fps
Radeon HD 7970M (8.934.2.0) / Core i7-3610QM
Alienware M17x R4
28.12 fps -5%
GeForce GTX 680M (302.72) / Core i7-3720QM
Schenker XMG P702
10.92 fps -63%
GeForce GTX 770M (311.27) / Core i7-4800MQ
One K73-3N
11.11 fps -62%
GeForce GTX 780M (311.27) / Core i7-4700MQ
One K56-3N2
11.84 fps -60%
1920x1080 Pro/ENGINEER (sort by value)
Radeon HD 8970M (12.103.0.0) / Core i7-4700MQ
One K73-3N
3.66 fps
Radeon HD 7970M (8.934.2.0) / Core i7-3610QM
Alienware M17x R4
2.21 fps -40%
GeForce GTX 680M (302.72) / Core i7-3720QM
Schenker XMG P702
1.37 fps -63%
GeForce GTX 770M (311.27) / Core i7-4800MQ
One K73-3N
1.48 fps -60%
GeForce GTX 780M (311.27) / Core i7-4700MQ
One K56-3N2
1.41 fps -61%
1920x1080 Maya (sort by value)
Radeon HD 8970M (12.103.0.0) / Core i7-4700MQ
One K73-3N
16.68 fps
Radeon HD 7970M (8.934.2.0) / Core i7-3610QM
Alienware M17x R4
14.04 fps -16%
GeForce GTX 680M (302.72) / Core i7-3720QM
Schenker XMG P702
13.47 fps -19%
GeForce GTX 770M (311.27) / Core i7-4800MQ
One K73-3N
15.11 fps -9%
GeForce GTX 780M (311.27) / Core i7-4700MQ
One K56-3N2
15.39 fps -8%
1920x1080 Lightwave (sort by value)
Radeon HD 8970M (12.103.0.0) / Core i7-4700MQ
One K73-3N
32.24 fps
Radeon HD 7970M (8.934.2.0) / Core i7-3610QM
Alienware M17x R4
32.4 fps 0%
GeForce GTX 680M (302.72) / Core i7-3720QM
Schenker XMG P702
17.39 fps -46%
GeForce GTX 770M (311.27) / Core i7-4800MQ
One K73-3N
20.28 fps -37%
GeForce GTX 780M (311.27) / Core i7-4700MQ
One K56-3N2
18.26 fps -43%
1920x1080 Ensight (sort by value)
Radeon HD 8970M (12.103.0.0) / Core i7-4700MQ
One K73-3N
51.7 fps
Radeon HD 7970M (8.934.2.0) / Core i7-3610QM
Alienware M17x R4
37.03 fps -28%
GeForce GTX 680M (302.72) / Core i7-3720QM
Schenker XMG P702
22.73 fps -56%
GeForce GTX 770M (311.27) / Core i7-4800MQ
One K73-3N
19.74 fps -62%
GeForce GTX 780M (311.27) / Core i7-4700MQ
One K56-3N2
22.71 fps -56%
1920x1080 Catia (sort by value)
Radeon HD 8970M (12.103.0.0) / Core i7-4700MQ
One K73-3N
10.81 fps
Radeon HD 7970M (8.934.2.0) / Core i7-3610QM
Alienware M17x R4
6.64 fps -39%
GeForce GTX 680M (302.72) / Core i7-3720QM
Schenker XMG P702
6.77 fps -37%
GeForce GTX 770M (311.27) / Core i7-4800MQ
One K73-3N
11.9 fps +10%
GeForce GTX 780M (311.27) / Core i7-4700MQ
One K56-3N2
12.42 fps +15%

Oyun performansı

Tüm oyunları özetlemek gerekirse: Radeon HD 8970M aradaki 300 Euroluk fiyat farkına karşın GeForce GTX 770M grafik kartına göre %20 daha hızlı. GTX 780M ile arasındaki fark ise gayet küçük. Bizde %15lik performans farkı satın almayı haklı kılmıyor. Ancak gelecek sürücü versiyonları performans farklılıklarını değiştirebilir. Radeon HD 7970M ve GeForce GTX 680M gibi eski modeller ise %10 kadar daha yavaş.

 

Company of Heroes 2 - 1920x1080 Maximum / Higher / High AA:High (sort by value)
Radeon HD 8970M (12.103.0.0) / Core i7-4700MQ
One K73-3N
22.8 fps
Radeon HD 7970M (mixed) / Core i7-3610QM
Schenker XMG P502
22.1 fps -3%
GeForce GTX 680M (mixed) / Core i7-3610QM
Schenker XMG P502
18.4 fps -19%
GeForce GTX 770M (320.49) / Core i7-4700MQ
One K73-3N
15.4 fps -32%
GeForce GTX 780M (320.49) / Core i7-4700MQ
One K73-3N
23.3 fps +2%
GRID 2 - 1920x1080 Ultra Preset AA:4xMS (sort by value)
Radeon HD 8970M (12.103.0.0) / Core i7-4700MQ
One K73-3N
62.2 fps
Radeon HD 7970M (mixed) / Core i7-3610QM
Schenker XMG P502
58.7 fps -6%
GeForce GTX 680M (mixed) / Core i7-3610QM
Schenker XMG P502
48.2 fps -23%
GeForce GTX 770M (320.49) / Core i7-4700MQ
One K73-3N
49 fps -21%
GeForce GTX 780M (320.49) / Core i7-4700MQ
One K73-3N
71 fps +14%
Metro: Last Light - 1920x1080 Very High (DX11) AF:16x (sort by value)
Radeon HD 8970M (12.103.0.0) / Core i7-4700MQ
One K73-3N
31.9 fps
Radeon HD 7970M (mixed) / Core i7-3610QM
Schenker XMG P502
31 fps -3%
GeForce GTX 680M (mixed) / Core i7-3610QM
Schenker XMG P502
30.5 fps -4%
GeForce GTX 770M (320.49) / Core i7-4700MQ
One K73-3N
26.7 fps -16%
GeForce GTX 780M (320.49) / Core i7-4700MQ
One K73-3N
41 fps +29%
BioShock Infinite - 1920x1080 Ultra Preset, DX11 (DDOF) (sort by value)
Radeon HD 8970M (12.103.0.0) / Core i7-4700MQ
One K73-3N
43.7 fps
Radeon HD 7970M (mixed) / Core i7-3610QM
Schenker XMG P502
43.7 fps 0%
GeForce GTX 680M (mixed) / Core i7-3610QM
Schenker XMG P502
46.6 fps +7%
GeForce GTX 770M (311.27) / Core i7-4800MQ
One K73-3N
30.8 fps -30%
GeForce GTX 780M (311.27) / Core i7-4700MQ
One K56-3N2
46.6 fps +7%
SimCity - 1920x1080 Ultra / High AA:on (sort by value)
Radeon HD 8970M (12.103.0.0) / Core i7-4700MQ
One K73-3N
44.4 fps
Radeon HD 7970M (mixed) / Core i7-3610QM
Schenker XMG P502
30.7 fps -31%
GeForce GTX 680M (mixed) / Core i7-3610QM
Schenker XMG P502
32.1 fps -28%
GeForce GTX 770M (311.27) / Core i7-4800MQ
One K73-3N
29.5 fps -34%
GeForce GTX 780M (311.27) / Core i7-4700MQ
One K56-3N2
39.9 fps -10%
Tomb Raider - 1920x1080 Ultra Preset AA:FX AF:16x (sort by value)
Radeon HD 8970M (12.103.0.0) / Core i7-4700MQ
One K73-3N
61.7 fps
Radeon HD 7970M (mixed) / Core i7-3610QM
Schenker XMG P502
46 fps -25%
GeForce GTX 680M (mixed) / Core i7-3610QM
Schenker XMG P502
32.2 fps -48%
GeForce GTX 770M (311.27) / Core i7-4800MQ
One K73-3N
41.9 fps -32%
GeForce GTX 780M (311.27) / Core i7-4700MQ
One K56-3N2
65.3 fps +6%
Crysis 3 - 1920x1080 Very High Preset AA:2xSM AF:16x (sort by value)
Radeon HD 8970M (12.103.0.0) / Core i7-4700MQ
One K73-3N
23.4 fps
Radeon HD 7970M (mixed) / Core i7-3610QM
Schenker XMG P502
20.3 fps -13%
GeForce GTX 680M (mixed) / Core i7-3610QM
Schenker XMG P502
21.8 fps -7%
GeForce GTX 770M (311.27) / Core i7-4800MQ
One K73-3N
19.3 fps -18%
GeForce GTX 780M (311.27) / Core i7-4700MQ
One K56-3N2
29.3 fps +25%
Dead Space 3 - 1920x1080 Very High Preset (sort by value)
Radeon HD 8970M (12.103.0.0) / Core i7-4700MQ
One K73-3N
109.4 fps
Radeon HD 7970M (mixed) / Core i7-3610QM
Schenker XMG P502
92.3 fps -16%
GeForce GTX 680M (mixed) / Core i7-3610QM
Schenker XMG P502
111.1 fps +2%
GeForce GTX 770M (311.27) / Core i7-4800MQ
One K73-3N
93 fps -15%
GeForce GTX 780M (311.27) / Core i7-4700MQ
One K56-3N2
144.2 fps +32%
Far Cry 3 - 1920x1080 DX11 Ultra Preset (HDAO, Enhanced Alpha To Coverage) AA:4x MS (sort by value)
Radeon HD 8970M (12.103.0.0) / Core i7-4700MQ
One K73-3N
28.3 fps
Radeon HD 7970M (Cat. 12.11) / Core i7-3610QM
Schenker XMG P502
25.4 fps -10%
GeForce GTX 680M (mixed) / Core i7-3610QM
Schenker XMG P502
23.6 fps -17%
GeForce GTX 770M (311.27) / Core i7-4800MQ
One K73-3N
20 fps -29%
GeForce GTX 780M (311.27) / Core i7-4700MQ
One K56-3N2
30.4 fps +7%
Assassin´s Creed III - 1920x1080 Very High (sort by value)
Radeon HD 8970M (12.103.0.0) / Core i7-4700MQ
One K73-3N
28.4 fps
Radeon HD 7970M (Cat. 12.11) / Core i7-3610QM
Schenker XMG P502
24.7 fps -13%
GeForce GTX 680M (mixed) / Core i7-3610QM
Schenker XMG P502
34.1 fps +20%
GeForce GTX 770M (311.27) / Core i7-4800MQ
One K73-3N
30.5 fps +7%
GeForce GTX 780M (311.27) / Core i7-4700MQ
One K56-3N2
42.6 fps +50%
Hitman: Absolution - 1920x1080 Ultra Preset AA:4xMS AF:16x (sort by value)
Radeon HD 8970M (12.103.0.0) / Core i7-4700MQ
One K73-3N
35.2 fps
Radeon HD 7970M (Cat. 12.11) / Core i7-3610QM
Schenker XMG P502
28.8 fps -18%
GeForce GTX 680M (mixed) / Core i7-3610QM
Schenker XMG P502
22.6 fps -36%
GeForce GTX 770M (311.27) / Core i7-4800MQ
One K73-3N
21.2 fps -40%
GeForce GTX 780M (311.27) / Core i7-4700MQ
One K56-3N2
33.8 fps -4%
Call of Duty: Black Ops 2 - 1920x1080 (Extra) High / On, FXAA AA:4xMS (sort by value)
Radeon HD 8970M (12.103.0.0) / Core i7-4700MQ
One K73-3N
84.2 fps
Radeon HD 7970M (Cat. 12.11) / Core i7-3610QM
Schenker XMG P502
75 fps -11%
GeForce GTX 680M (mixed) / Core i7-3610QM
Schenker XMG P502
75.3 fps -11%
GeForce GTX 770M (311.27) / Core i7-4800MQ
One K73-3N
66.1 fps -21%
GeForce GTX 780M (311.27) / Core i7-4700MQ
One K56-3N2
95.1 fps +13%
Need for Speed: Most Wanted - 1920x1080 High / On (sort by value)
Radeon HD 8970M (12.103.0.0) / Core i7-4700MQ
One K73-3N
53.6 fps
Radeon HD 7970M (Cat. 12.11) / Core i7-3610QM
Schenker XMG P502
48.4 fps -10%
GeForce GTX 680M (mixed) / Core i7-3610QM
Schenker XMG P502
51.4 fps -4%
GeForce GTX 770M (311.27) / Core i7-4800MQ
One K73-3N
46.9 fps -12%
GeForce GTX 780M (311.27) / Core i7-4700MQ
One K56-3N2
59.9 fps +12%
Medal of Honor: Warfighter - 1920x1080 Ultra Preset AA:4xMS AF:16x (sort by value)
Radeon HD 8970M (12.103.0.0) / Core i7-4700MQ
One K73-3N
47.7 fps
Radeon HD 7970M (Cat. 12.11) / Core i7-3610QM
Schenker XMG P502
46.2 fps -3%
GeForce GTX 680M (mixed) / Core i7-3610QM
Schenker XMG P502
40.9 fps -14%
GeForce GTX 770M (311.27) / Core i7-4800MQ
One K73-3N
36 fps -25%
GeForce GTX 780M (311.27) / Core i7-4700MQ
One K56-3N2
54.8 fps +15%
Dishonored - 1920x1080 High / On, FOV: 75 AA:FX (sort by value)
Radeon HD 8970M (12.103.0.0) / Core i7-4700MQ
One K73-3N
112 fps
Radeon HD 7970M (mixed) / Core i7-3610QM
Schenker XMG P502
99.9 fps -11%
GeForce GTX 680M (mixed) / Core i7-3610QM
Schenker XMG P502
115.7 fps +3%
GeForce GTX 770M (311.27) / Core i7-4800MQ
One K73-3N
108.7 fps -3%
GeForce GTX 780M (311.27) / Core i7-4700MQ
One K56-3N2
125 fps +12%
Fifa 13 - 1920x1080 High AA:4xMS (sort by value)
Radeon HD 8970M (12.103.0.0) / Core i7-4700MQ
One K73-3N
295.4 fps
Radeon HD 7970M (mixed) / Core i7-3610QM
Schenker XMG P502
226.6 fps -23%
GeForce GTX 680M (mixed) / Core i7-3610QM
Schenker XMG P502
256.9 fps -13%
GeForce GTX 770M (311.27) / Core i7-4800MQ
One K73-3N
291.9 fps -1%
GeForce GTX 780M (311.27) / Core i7-4700MQ
One K56-3N2
307.7 fps +4%
Borderlands 2 - 1920x1080 (Ultra) High / On (PhysX low) AA:FX AF:8x (sort by value)
Radeon HD 8970M (12.103.0.0) / Core i7-4700MQ
One K73-3N
69.9 fps
Radeon HD 7970M (mixed) / Core i7-3610QM
Schenker XMG P502
62.9 fps -10%
GeForce GTX 680M (mixed) / Core i7-3610QM
Schenker XMG P502
71.1 fps +2%
GeForce GTX 770M (311.27) / Core i7-4800MQ
One K73-3N
64.3 fps -8%
GeForce GTX 780M (311.27) / Core i7-4700MQ
One K56-3N2
83.3 fps +19%
F1 2012 - 1920x1080 Ultra Preset AA:4xMS (sort by value)
Radeon HD 8970M (12.103.0.0) / Core i7-4700MQ
One K73-3N
65 fps
GeForce GTX 680M (mixed) / Core i7-3610QM
Schenker XMG P502
87 fps +34%
GeForce GTX 770M (311.27) / Core i7-4800MQ
One K73-3N
76 fps +17%
GeForce GTX 780M (311.27) / Core i7-4700MQ
One K56-3N2
100 fps +54%
Guild Wars 2 - 1920x1080 All Maximum / On AA:FX (sort by value)
Radeon HD 8970M (12.103.0.0) / Core i7-4700MQ
One K73-3N
39.7 fps
Radeon HD 7970M (mixed) / Core i7-3610QM
Schenker XMG P502
30.6 fps -23%
GeForce GTX 680M (mixed) / Core i7-3610QM
Schenker XMG P502
31.9 fps -20%
GeForce GTX 770M (311.27) / Core i7-4800MQ
One K73-3N
28.6 fps -28%
GeForce GTX 780M (311.27) / Core i7-4700MQ
One K56-3N2
41.2 fps +4%
Counter-Strike: GO - 1920x1080 (Very) High, FXAA AA:4x MS AF:8x (sort by value)
Radeon HD 8970M (12.103.0.0) / Core i7-4700MQ
One K73-3N
194.1 fps
Radeon HD 7970M (mixed) / Core i7-3610QM
Schenker XMG P502
153.5 fps -21%
GeForce GTX 680M (mixed) / Core i7-3610QM
Schenker XMG P502
128 fps -34%
GeForce GTX 770M (311.27) / Core i7-4800MQ
One K73-3N
150.9 fps -22%
GeForce GTX 780M (311.27) / Core i7-4700MQ
One K56-3N2
194 fps 0%
Sleeping Dogs - 1920x1080 Extreme Preset AA:Extreme (sort by value)
Radeon HD 8970M (12.103.0.0) / Core i7-4700MQ
One K73-3N
30.2 fps
Radeon HD 7970M (mixed) / Core i7-3610QM
Schenker XMG P502
28.5 fps -6%
GeForce GTX 680M (mixed) / Core i7-3610QM
Schenker XMG P502
22.7 fps -25%
GeForce GTX 770M (311.27) / Core i7-4800MQ
One K73-3N
19.3 fps -36%
GeForce GTX 780M (311.27) / Core i7-4700MQ
One K56-3N2
30.8 fps +2%
Darksiders II - 1920x1080 2/4 Shadows, No Ambient Occlusion, AA:Low (sort by value)
Radeon HD 8970M (12.103.0.0) / Core i7-4700MQ
One K73-3N
121.1 fps
Radeon HD 7970M (mixed) / Core i7-3610QM
Schenker XMG P502
104.1 fps -14%
GeForce GTX 680M (mixed) / Core i7-3610QM
Schenker XMG P502
108.8 fps -10%
GeForce GTX 770M (311.27) / Core i7-4800MQ
One K73-3N
91.3 fps -25%
GeForce GTX 780M (311.27) / Core i7-4700MQ
One K56-3N2
136.9 fps +13%
Max Payne 3 - 1920x1080 Very High, DX11 AA:Very High FX AF:8x (sort by value)
Radeon HD 8970M (12.103.0.0) / Core i7-4700MQ
One K73-3N
61.4 fps
GeForce GTX 680M (302.75) / Core i7-3610QM
DevilTech Devil 6700
42.6 fps -31%
GeForce GTX 770M (311.27) / Core i7-4800MQ
One K73-3N
37.1 fps -40%
GeForce GTX 780M (311.27) / Core i7-4700MQ
One K56-3N2
54.5 fps -11%
Dirt Showdown - 1920x1080 Ultra Preset AA:4xMS (sort by value)
Radeon HD 8970M (12.103.0.0) / Core i7-4700MQ
One K73-3N
55.8 fps
Radeon HD 7970M (8.934.2.0) / Core i7-3610QM
Alienware M14x R4
48.7 fps -13%
GeForce GTX 680M (302.75) / Core i7-3610QM
DevilTech Devil 6700
52.9 fps -5%
GeForce GTX 770M (311.27) / Core i7-4800MQ
One K73-3N
45.2 fps -19%
GeForce GTX 780M (311.27) / Core i7-4700MQ
One K56-3N2
66.4 fps +19%
Diablo III - 1920x1080 High AA:on (sort by value)
Radeon HD 8970M (12.103.0.0) / Core i7-4700MQ
One K73-3N
115.8 fps
Radeon HD 7970M (8.934.2.0) / Core i7-3610QM
Alienware M14x R4
100.8 fps -13%
GeForce GTX 680M (302.75) / Core i7-3610QM
DevilTech Devil 6700
159.6 fps +38%
GeForce GTX 770M (311.27) / Core i7-4800MQ
One K73-3N
141.3 fps +22%
GeForce GTX 780M (311.27) / Core i7-4700MQ
One K56-3N2
188 fps +62%
Risen 2: Dark Waters - 1920x1080 Ultra / on AA:on AF:8x (sort by value)
Radeon HD 8970M (12.103.0.0) / Core i7-4700MQ
One K73-3N
48.4 fps
Radeon HD 7970M (8.934.2.0) / Core i7-3610QM
Alienware M14x R4
43.1 fps -11%
GeForce GTX 680M (302.75) / Core i7-3610QM
DevilTech Devil 6700
42.2 fps -13%
GeForce GTX 770M (311.27) / Core i7-4800MQ
One K73-3N
35.6 fps -26%
GeForce GTX 780M (311.27) / Core i7-4700MQ
One K56-3N2
53.8 fps +11%
Alan Wake - 1920x1080 High Preset AA:4x AF:8x (sort by value)
Radeon HD 8970M (12.103.0.0) / Core i7-4700MQ
One K73-3N
49.2 fps
Radeon HD 7970M (8.934.2.0) / Core i7-3610QM
Alienware M14x R4
44.7 fps -9%
GeForce GTX 680M (302.75) / Core i7-3610QM
DevilTech Devil 6700
41.9 fps -15%
GeForce GTX 770M (311.27) / Core i7-4800MQ
One K73-3N
35.2 fps -28%
GeForce GTX 780M (311.27) / Core i7-4700MQ
One K56-3N2
54.1 fps +10%
Anno 2070 - 1920x1080 Very High Preset AA:on AF:4x (sort by value)
Radeon HD 8970M (12.103.0.0) / Core i7-4700MQ
One K73-3N
58.9 fps
Radeon HD 7970M (8.934.2.0) / Core i7-3610QM
Alienware M14x R4
55.4 fps -6%
GeForce GTX 680M (302.75) / Core i7-3610QM
DevilTech Devil 6700
51 fps -13%
GeForce GTX 770M (311.27) / Core i7-4800MQ
One K73-3N
47.2 fps -20%
GeForce GTX 780M (311.27) / Core i7-4700MQ
One K56-3N2
72.6 fps +23%
The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim - 1920x1080 Ultra Preset AA:8x AF:16x (sort by value)
Radeon HD 8970M (12.103.0.0) / Core i7-4700MQ
One K73-3N
59.2 fps
Radeon HD 7970M (8.934.2.0) / Core i7-3610QM
Alienware M14x R4
55.6 fps -6%
GeForce GTX 680M (302.75) / Core i7-3610QM
DevilTech Devil 6700
54.2 fps -8%
GeForce GTX 770M (311.27) / Core i7-4800MQ
One K73-3N
49 fps -17%
GeForce GTX 780M (311.27) / Core i7-4700MQ
One K56-3N2
68.3 fps +15%
CoD: Modern Warfare 3 - 1920x1080 Extra, all on, Image Quality: Native AA:4x (sort by value)
Radeon HD 8970M (12.103.0.0) / Core i7-4700MQ
One K73-3N
109.2 fps
Radeon HD 7970M (8.934.2.0) / Core i7-3610QM
Alienware M14x R4
90.7 fps -17%
GeForce GTX 680M (302.75) / Core i7-3610QM
DevilTech Devil 6700
102.8 fps -6%
GeForce GTX 770M (311.27) / Core i7-4800MQ
One K73-3N
91.4 fps -16%
GeForce GTX 780M (311.27) / Core i7-4700MQ
One K56-3N2
117.3 fps +7%
Battlefield 3 - 1920x1080 ultra AA:4x MS AF:16x (sort by value)
Radeon HD 8970M (12.103.0.0) / Core i7-4700MQ
One K73-3N
45.3 fps
Radeon HD 7970M (8.934.2.0) / Core i7-3610QM
Alienware M14x R4
34.7 fps -23%
GeForce GTX 680M (302.75) / Core i7-3610QM
DevilTech Devil 6700
34.7 fps -23%
GeForce GTX 770M (311.27) / Core i7-4800MQ
One K73-3N
32.6 fps -28%
GeForce GTX 780M (311.27) / Core i7-4700MQ
One K56-3N2
50 fps +10%

Sistem sesi

Laptop üreticisi fan kontrolüne çok emek harcamayıp, sıcaklığa odaklanmış. One K73-3N ister GTX 770M, HD 8970M veya GTX 780M kullansın, ses üretimi aynı. Ancak diğer notebooklarda bu durum değişecektir.

System noise: One K73-3N (Clevo P170SM)

Sıcaklık

Sıcaklık değerlerinde ise farklar büyük. Radeon HD 8970M 72 derece ile GeForce GTX 770M'in 67 derecesine yakın. Ancak GeForce GTX 780M'in 86 derecesi bizi biraz endişelendiriyor. Bekleme modunda ise sıcaklık değerleri 38 ile 41 derece arlığında. Eğer GPU-Z doğru ise Nvidia grafik kartları AMD'ye kıyasla daha da düşük sıcaklıklara sahip.

Bekleme sıcaklık: HD 8970M
Bekleme sıcaklık: HD 8970M
Bekleme sıcaklık: GTX 770M
Bekleme sıcaklık: GTX 770M
Bekleme sıcaklık: GTX 780M
Bekleme sıcaklık: GTX 780M
Yoğun kullanımda sıcaklık: HD 8970M
Yoğun kullanımda sıcaklık: HD 8970M
Yoğun kullanımda sıcaklık: GTX 770M
Yoğun kullanımda sıcaklık: GTX 770M
Yoğun kullanımda sıcaklık: GTX 780M
Yoğun kullanımda sıcaklık: GTX 780M


Temperaturen One K73-3N (Clevo P170SM)

Güç tüketimi

Güç tüketiminde ne AMD ne de Nvidia kazanıyor. Grafik kartı değişimi sayesinde K73-3N her bir grafik kartı ile bekleme modunda 24-25 Watt gibi bir güce ihtiyaç duymakta. Yoğun kullanımda ise güç tüketimi 138 Watt ile GeForce GTX 770M ve GTX 780M aralığında kalıyor.

Stromverbrauch One K73-3N (Clevo P170SM)

Sonuç

from left to right: GTX 780M, HD 8970M, GTX 770M
AMD vs. Nvidia

Radeon HD 8970M iyi bir üst sınıf kart olduğunu kanıtlıyor. Eğer sorunsuz bir sürücü kullanırsanız, DirectX 11 sorunsuz çalışmakta. Grafik kartı değiştirme halen Nvidia'nınki kadar iyi çalışmasa da, deneyimli oyuncular bu konunun üstesinden gelecektir.

Fiyat/performans oranı özellikle etkileyici. Radeon HD 7970M gibi bu yeni kartta fiyatı için gayet iyi bir performans sunmakta. Nvidia kesinlikle modellerinin fiyatlarını gözden geçirmeli. Özellikle GeForce GTX 770M ve GeForce GTX 780M testlerinin sonucuna bakıldığında, fiyat/performansın makul olmadığını görüyoruz.

Genel olarak Radeon HD 8970M'in en makul üst sınıf kart olduğu kanaatindeyiz. En iyi grafik kartını kimin ürettiği göreceli olsa da, şu kesin: AMD kaotik bir lansmanı kaldıramaz.

Please share our article, every link counts!
Mail Logo
> Notebooklar Hakkında Aradığınız Herşey > İnceleme > İnceleme: AMD Radeon HD 8970M
Florian Glaser (Update: 2018-05-15)